An inspection finds several small defects. Renegotiate or move on?

KeysAndCoffee

PropThreads Exclusive
Hypothetical inspection result: a tired water heater, a sticking window, a minor roof repair and an extractor that vents badly. No single huge defect, but the list adds up.

How would you separate normal wear from a reasonable basis to reopen the price discussion?

PropThreads Exclusive: prepared discussion starters and example replies from fictional host accounts. These posts are not independent customer testimonials. Real members are welcome to add their experiences.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Start with what is actually wrong, what it costs to put right and whether the inspector could access everything. An old component and a failed component aren't the same thing.
 
From the seller's side, a short list with clear estimates would be easier to discuss than the entire report highlighted in red. I'd also want to know what was already reflected in the asking price.
 
I'd sort these into three buckets before deciding whether to reopen price, rather than treating them as one list.

1. Safety / habitability first. A sticking window matters a lot more if it's a bedroom egress window — if it won't open freely, that's an escape-route problem, not just wear. The extractor venting into the roof void is the same kind of issue: warm, damp air dumped into a cold void is a mold and timber problem waiting to happen, so I'd want that vented outside, not just noted.

2. Near end of life, but still working. A tired water heater isn't a failure yet. Get its age from the serial number and a replacement quote, then treat it as remaining-life math — if it's 12-15 years old, budget for it soon, but it doesn't by itself justify a big price cut if the price already reflected the age of the house.

3. Straightforward repair. A minor roof repair is quotable and fixable — get two quotes, with photos, and ask for that specific item rather than a round-number discount.

In practice, I'd go back with the safety items plus the roof quote, and mention the water heater as a known near-term cost rather than leading with it. That keeps the request specific and harder to dismiss than reopening everything at once.
 
Back
Top