Berlin mortgage quote: 5.36% fixed for 10 years on €1,247,000—what should I compare?

celine.archer

Homeowner
Established
I need to choose soon, but the cheapest-looking offer may not be the safest one. The purchase is around €1,247,000 in Berlin, and the quote is 5.36% fixed for 10 years. Once the fees and applicable loan-to-value band are included, the gap between this and the other options is not what the headline rates suggest.

Because the monthly payments are all affordable, I am leaning towards comparing them over the period I might realistically keep the loan. I plan to ask for the upfront charges, payment schedule and balance remaining in year ten in one table. I also need the exact early-repayment and portability terms, particularly if I move before then.

Is there another figure that would expose the refinancing risk more clearly? I also want the adviser to state whether payment or commission varies by lender, as that could affect how I read the recommendation.
 
Use APR as a first filter, but I wouldn’t make the decision from that alone. Put every offer into the same 10-year cash-flow table: upfront fees, monthly payments, total paid, and remaining balance at the end of the fixed period. That last figure matters because it is the amount exposed to the future refinancing rate. A slightly cheaper payment can hide a larger balance in year ten.
 
I partly disagree that the 10-year total should dominate. If there is a realistic chance you will sell, move or repay early, the cheapest full-term projection may be irrelevant. What do the offers actually say about portability and early repayment, and how likely are you to need either? Also, are they based on identical deposit amounts and repayment schedules? Otherwise the APR comparison is not truly like-for-like.
 
Given the deadline, ask for one side-by-side illustration using the same loan amount, loan-to-value, repayment assumptions and 10-year period. Have it show fees, monthly payment, remaining balance after ten years, and the cost of an early exit under a couple of plausible dates. Then stress-test affordability at a higher refinance rate rather than assuming today’s rate continues. Separately, ask the adviser plainly how they are paid and whether compensation differs between the offers.
 
Back
Top