Chicago 3-bed at $800k: adjusting one closed comparable

cai.ash

Market analyst
Market Reporter
I’m assessing a 3-bed serviced apartment in Chicago: approximately 1,940 sq ft, average condition, asking $800,000. Light and location are the main positives; dated finishes and possible building reserve costs are the concerns.

I found three asking-price comparables but only one completed sale, and the nearest completed examples otherwise differ substantially. At this stage, what range would you use for floor area and condition adjustments? Also, which single missing fact would most change the valuation?

For the rental fallback I allowed eleven months of rent, but I am not convinced the repair reserve is sufficient. That approach only works if the assumed exit timing is realistic. I’ll obtain a formal local appraisal before relying on any figure.
 
The asking price is roughly $412 per sq ft, but I would not apply a standard percentage adjustment from that alone. Extra floor area is usually worth a marginal rate, not necessarily the comp’s full average rate. For condition, estimate the work required and then allow for buyer disruption rather than using a broad label like “average.”

My most important missing fact would be the building’s current service charges and reserve position, including any known major work.
 
What does “serviced” involve here? Is there an operating or management arrangement, and if so, what is its remaining term and cost? That could affect both the rental calculation and the relevant buyer pool.

I’d also want to know whether the completed sale is in the same building and whether parking or outdoor space is included on either side. Those differences can overwhelm a neat floor-area adjustment.
 
I’d put micro-location and the quality of the completed comparable ahead of a generic condition allowance. A closed sale in the same building, with similar light and floor position, could be useful even if its finishes differ. A nearby sale in a different building may be much weaker evidence.

I partly disagree that reserves are automatically the biggest missing item. They matter greatly to the offer, but first establish whether the sale comp is genuinely comparable.
 
Fair distinction, although reserve weakness can feed directly into market value if buyers anticipate higher charges or a substantial building expense. I would build a simple grid: completed price, sale timing, building/micro-location, floor area, condition, light, parking and outdoor space. Keep uncertain items blank rather than forcing an adjustment, and avoid counting dated finishes both as renovation cost and again as a broad condition discount.
 
The eleven-month rent assumption also needs to be tested on a net basis. Service charges, operating restrictions, repairs and any management costs can matter more than the vacancy allowance itself. For the exit, I’d run several timing scenarios rather than one fallback date and see whether the deal still works without assuming the three asking comparables actually achieve their prices.
 
This helps. I was giving the asking comparables too much weight and trying to force a floor-area range before establishing whether the closed sale is a sound anchor.

My next step is to obtain the completed sale’s building and unit details, then confirm parking, outdoor space, the service arrangement and any lease term, plus current charges and reserve information. I’ll price identifiable refurbishment separately and test the rental fallback using net income and more than one exit timeline.
 
Back
Top