Comparing a 2.89% 20-year fixed quote on a $1,235,000 New York purchase

eden_chase

First-time buyer
Founding Member
I stripped out the sales pitch from a mortgage quote for a New York property purchase around $1,235,000. The offer is 2.89% fixed for 20 years, but the advertised rate was lower before arrangement fees and the applicable loan-to-value tier were included.

What should carry the most weight when comparing lenders: APR, interest over the fixed period, or total cash cost including fees? I am also checking monthly affordability, portability and early-repayment terms. Most paperwork is complete, but one outstanding written answer could change the calculation, so I would rather not rely on another confident phone explanation.
 
Compare total cash cost over the period you realistically expect to keep this loan, not automatically over 20 years. Include upfront fees, scheduled payments, and any cost of repaying when you might sell or refinance. APR is a useful first filter, but it can mislead if your actual holding period is much shorter.

Also confirm in writing whether “20-year fixed” means a fully amortizing 20-year loan with no rate reset, and what loan amount produces the quoted LTV tier.
 
I would not rank portability highly until the lender explains exactly what it means here; selling and obtaining another mortgage may make that feature irrelevant. Early-repayment terms and the fee-adjusted cost at several possible exit dates are more concrete.

Build three comparisons: keeping the loan for a short period, a medium period, and all 20 years. Do not assume refinancing will be available or cheaper. Separately test whether the monthly payment remains comfortable without a refinance. The missing written answer should be resolved before treating 2.89% as comparable with other quotes.
 
Back
Top