Comparing a 7.29% 20-year fixed mortgage quote in Tokyo

DirectLane

First-time buyer
The headline number is not the part troubling me. It is whether the full cost makes this Tokyo loan workable without relying on a future escape route.

The property is around ¥114,800,000, and the quote is 7.29% fixed for 20 years. Fees and the lending tier pushed the real cost well beyond what the initial promotion suggested. When comparing offers, should I calculate all cash paid over the period I expect to keep the loan, including setup costs, and also compare the balance remaining at that point?

I also want the written conditions for partial or full early repayment and any portability option. The broker expects refinancing to be available later, but I would prefer the purchase to stand up financially even if that never happens.
 
I would compare total cash cost on identical assumptions: same loan amount, repayment schedule, fixed period and planned holding period. Include every upfront fee, then show the remaining balance at the end of the comparison period. APR can be useful, but only if each lender calculates it on a genuinely comparable basis. Ask for the full payment schedule rather than relying on the headline rate.
 
One missing detail: is ¥114,800,000 the purchase price or the amount being borrowed? Also, is 20 years the entire loan term or merely the fixed-rate period? Those answers materially affect both the monthly affordability test and the risk you face when the rate resets.
 
I’d be cautious about using an expected holding period as the main comparison. Plans change, and selling or refinancing may be expensive or unavailable at the convenient moment. Run a base case where you keep this loan exactly as quoted and make no refinancing assumption. If that monthly payment is uncomfortable, a future refinance should not be treated as the solution.
 
For portability and early repayment, I’d ask the broker to put the mechanics and costs in writing rather than simply confirming that they are “available.” Your comparison sheet could have columns for upfront cash, monthly payments, total paid after 5, 10 and 20 years, balance remaining, early-repayment cost, and what happens if you move. That should expose where the lower advertised rate stops being cheaper.
 
The loan-to-value tier may be doing more work here than the arrangement fee. Ask for side-by-side illustrations at different down-payment amounts, if those options are realistic for you. That shows whether adding cash meaningfully improves the terms or merely shifts money from your reserves into the property. I would not drain the affordability buffer solely to reach a better-looking rate.
 
Thanks, this has clarified the comparison. ¥114,800,000 is the purchase price, not necessarily the final loan amount, and I should have separated those figures. I’ve asked for two full illustrations using the same borrowing amount: one assuming no refinance for the full 20 years, and one showing the broker’s refinance scenario with its assumptions stated. I’m also requesting actual early-repayment and portability costs rather than yes/no answers.
 
That is the right direction. I’d add one stress case for a delayed or impossible refinance and compare its payment with your normal monthly budget, not just lender eligibility. Keep enough cash outside the transaction for ownership costs and surprises. Once the illustrations arrive, the key comparison is not 7.29% versus the advertisement; it is the all-in cost and flexibility of each offer available at your actual loan-to-value.
 
Back
Top