First time posting: mortgage quote in Australia: 4.83% fixed for 20 years?

loft.balanced

First-time buyer
Established
I have checked the quoted rate, upfront charges and repayment illustrations, but the comparison is still unclear because the lenders used different assumptions. The purchase is around A$1,056,000, and one offer is fixed at 4.83% for 20 years; its loan-to-value band also affects the cost.

Should I ask both lenders to rerun the figures over an identical period and show fees paid upfront separately from anything added to the balance? The lowest headline rate may not produce the better outcome once monthly repayments, portability and early-payment conditions are considered. I’m also unsure whether 20 years is being presented as the fixed period, the full term, or both.
 
I’d compare total cash paid over the same period, using the same loan amount, repayment schedule and fee treatment for both offers. APR can be a useful first filter, but it won’t resolve illustrations built on different assumptions. Show upfront fees separately from any fees added to the loan, because financed fees also affect interest.
 
What are the actual loan amount and loan-to-value ratio after your deposit? Also, is 20 years both the fixed period and the full loan term, or does the mortgage continue afterward? Without those details, total-interest figures may not be comparable. I’d ask each lender to rerun the illustration using one settlement date and identical repayment assumptions.
 
I wouldn’t make total cash over 20 years the only test. It effectively assumes you keep this exact loan for the entire fixed period. If you sell, refinance or make extra repayments, portability conditions and early-repayment costs could matter more than a modest difference in headline rate. Those terms can depend on the contract and circumstances, so they need to be compared directly in the offers.
 
That’s fair, but I’d still calculate the hold-to-term case as the baseline rather than assume refinancing will rescue a less competitive offer. Then add scenarios: moving after a few years, making extra repayments, and keeping the loan beyond any fixed period if the overall term is longer. For each one, compare monthly payments, remaining balance, fees and any rate-reset exposure.
 
A simple spreadsheet should settle most of this. Put both quotes on the same loan amount and timeline, then list: deposit/LTV tier, rate, monthly payment, upfront fees, financed fees, total interest, balance at each possible exit date, early-repayment conditions and portability limits. Any cell you cannot complete becomes a specific question for the lender. I’d also test whether the payment remains comfortable alongside normal ownership costs, not merely whether the application passes.
 
Back
Top