Is 4% below asking reasonable for this Mumbai warehouse?

fair_hill

Property investor
I can make the offer open-ended and risk drifting into a vague negotiation, or set a short expiry that may look artificial. Neither seems ideal. The Mumbai warehouse is listed at ₹27,970,000, has been on the market for 88 days and needs updating.

I am considering an opening offer 4% under the list price, with financing evidence and some flexibility over completion. The nearest closed comparable is older than I would like and had fewer inspection concerns, so it does not fully resolve the pricing question. There is also one outstanding issue whose verbal explanation has changed twice; I have now asked for the answer in writing.

Would a reasonable response date strengthen the offer without creating needless pressure? I do not want to give up inspection protection merely to make the terms look cleaner.
 
Four percent below does not sound overly aggressive after 88 days, particularly with work required. I’d include financing proof and a clear response date, but avoid an artificially short deadline. Flexibility on completion may matter more if the seller’s timing is driving the sale. Keep your inspection protection intact rather than trading it away to make the price look stronger.
 
Before choosing the deadline, I’d ask what the seller actually wants besides price. Is the warehouse vacant, and has the agent explained why it has sat for 88 days? Also clarify whether you want defects remedied, a repair credit, or simply reflected in the offer. Those approaches can produce very different negotiations.
 
I’d be more cautious than mapfold_daan. Time on the market and vague updating needs do not by themselves prove a 4% reduction is supported, especially when the best completed comparable is old. The clean financing helps, but it does not solve a valuation or appraisal gap.

Make the offer defensible line by line, require the disputed answer in writing, and ensure the deposit terms do not leave you exposed while inspections and financing are unresolved. If the seller counters, negotiate price and repair credits separately so the same defects are not counted twice.
 
Back
Top