Is 8% below asking reasonable for this Mexico City multifamily?

ravi_wilde

Homeowner
Established
I’m considering a small multifamily in Mexico City listed at MX$15,570,000. It has been available for 32 days and needs updating. The seller’s completed comparables are genuine, but every one has at least one feature this property lacks.

Would an opening offer 8% below asking, backed by clean financing and a flexible completion date, be sensible? If the seller challenges my comparable rather than the price, how should I answer?

There is also a proposed low-cost fix, but it is unclear who remains responsible if it fails. I want inspection protection and do not want a repair credit that merely transfers the risk to me.
 
Eight percent does not sound inherently unreasonable after only 32 days, but your explanation should be feature-by-feature rather than “your comparable is wrong.” Acknowledge each completed sale, then adjust your reasoning for what this building lacks and for the updating required.

Make the financing proof and flexible date part of the offer’s value. I would also give a clear response deadline so the seller has something definite to consider.
 
I’d be more cautious. Thirty-two days may not reveal much about seller motivation, and an 8% discount could distract from the bigger risk: the unresolved fix.

What is the inspection condition, and can you withdraw or renegotiate if the proposed solution is inadequate? Also, what happens to the deposit if financing is approved but the appraisal comes in below the agreed price? Those points could matter more than winning the opening negotiation.
 
Before choosing the number, have you separated the offer into three parts: value based on completed comparables, updating costs, and the uncertain repair? If the same issue is effectively deducted twice, the seller has a fair objection.

I would ask for either a completed remedy that can be inspected before closing or a credit sized only after the scope is understood. A cheap proposed fix is not necessarily a durable fix.
 
One caveat to my own suggestion: a credit may be unattractive if it leaves you carrying an open-ended problem. I’d put the inspection rights, deposit treatment, financing/appraisal protection, completion flexibility and response deadline in writing, with local professional input on the wording. Then present the 8% offer as a documented valuation position, not a test of how desperate the seller is.
 
Back
Top