Mortgage quote in New York: 7.37% fixed for 5 years—what should I compare before the next call?

quinn_grove

First-time buyer
My next lender calls are approaching, and I need a like-for-like comparison before then. One offer is 7.37% fixed for five years on a New York purchase of about $695,000; a more appealing headline figure did not survive the fees and the applicable loan-to-value band.

Should I compare APR first, cash paid over five years, or interest over that period plus every upfront charge? I’d like the lenders to show each measure using the same loan amount, term and payment assumptions rather than selecting whichever makes their offer look cheapest.

The payment at 7.37% has to fit now, but my partner’s bigger concern is the reset after year five. We do not want the calculation to depend on affordable refinancing being available. I also need the written early-repayment rules and an explanation of whether portability would actually help if we moved.

What scenarios should I request for the next call—monthly payments, fees, five-year balance, repayment charges and payments after the fixed period at several rates? I’m also checking whether the person recommending the mortgage shares any financial risk or only arranges the loan.
 
Back
Top