Offering 13% below asking on a Mexico City apartment before the deadline

ravi_wilde

Homeowner
Established
I’m considering an offer on a Mexico City apartment listed at MX$25,470,000. It has been available for 46 days and needs updating. The agent provided several examples, but only one seems genuinely comparable in both size and condition.

My proposed opening is 13% below asking—about MX$22,158,900—with clean financing and flexibility on completion. Should I explain the comparable and condition adjustment in the initial offer, or keep that evidence for a counteroffer? Most paperwork is complete, but I’m still investigating one outstanding item that could affect the calculation, and I need to decide before the response deadline.
 
I’d give a short rationale now, not save everything. State that the price reflects the closest completed comparable, the apartment’s condition, and your financing position. Attach proof of financing if appropriate, but don’t bury the seller in every example the agent supplied. Thirteen percent is assertive, yet it isn’t automatically unserious if the evidence supports it.
 
Is the one close example a completed transaction or merely another asking price? That changes how much weight I’d put on it. Also, what is the unresolved paperwork item, and does your offer retain inspection and appraisal protection? The percentage matters less than whether a low valuation or bad inspection could put your deposit at risk.
 
I’d be more cautious than Hassan. Forty-six days does not by itself show that the seller will accept a large reduction, and “needs updating” may already be reflected in the asking price. Seller motivation is the missing piece.

I also wouldn’t reduce the price for visible updating and then expect broad repair credits for the same work. Reserve any credit request for material issues found during inspection. If financing depends on appraisal, decide beforehand whether you would cover any gap or walk away, subject to the actual contract terms in Mexico City.
 
Agreed on avoiding double-counting. A practical offer could separate three things: the proposed price based on the completed comparable and known condition; inspection protection for unknown defects; and a clear limit on appraisal-gap or deposit exposure. Give a response deadline that fits the seller’s process rather than using an artificially short one. If they counter, then bring out the weaker examples only if they genuinely explain your number.
 
Back
Top