Offering 6% below asking on a Jakarta coastal home — sensible or too aggressive?

dara.river

First-time buyer
Founding Member
First post here. We are considering a coastal home in Jakarta listed at IDR 9,454,000,000. It has been available for 18 days and needs updating, but I can find plenty of asking prices and very few completed sales in genuinely comparable condition.

My proposed opening is IDR 8,886,760,000, which is 6% below asking, backed by clean financing and flexibility on completion. What term would make that stronger without leaving us with open-ended risk?

We do not want to produce a long list of minor defects. The concern is expensive unknowns. My partner cares less about the headline price than about discovering a major cost after completion, so I am trying to distinguish between a solution that removes risk and one that merely transfers it to us.
 
Six percent does not sound inherently aggressive, but 18 days alone says little about the seller’s willingness to move. I would pair the offer with financing evidence, a short response deadline and narrowly written inspection protection covering only costly unknowns.

An inspection right identifies risk; it does not remove it. A repair credit also leaves you arranging and carrying the work. Completion of agreed major repairs before closing, followed by verification, comes closer to removing that particular uncertainty.
 
What happens if the lender’s appraisal is below your agreed price? “Clean financing” can sound attractive to the seller, but do not accidentally promise to cover an unlimited appraisal gap or put the deposit at risk.

I would also ask the agent why the property is being sold and whether timing matters more than price. Flexible completion is valuable only if it matches the seller’s motivation.
 
I partly disagree about asking the seller to complete repairs. That can replace one uncertainty with another: rushed work, disputes over scope and delays to completion. For something expensive, a defined independent inspection, written estimates and a right to withdraw or renegotiate may be cleaner.

A capped credit is predictable but still transfers execution risk to the buyer. If your partner wants the risk genuinely reduced, focus on confirming condition before the deposit becomes exposed rather than trying to price every possible problem.
 
I would submit the 6% offer with four clear elements: proof of financing, the completion window the seller can choose from, a firm but reasonable response deadline, and inspection wording limited to major-cost items. Keep any appraisal protection and deposit conditions explicit.

If the seller counters, compare the counter with the few completed comparables you have, adjusted for condition—not with nearby asking figures. Then choose separately between price, verified pre-completion work and a credit. As Mila says, those options do not remove the same risks.
 
Back
Top