Phoenix warehouse at $360,000 after 107 days: is 9% below asking defensible?

fair_hill

Property investor
I’m considering an opening offer of $327,600 on a Phoenix warehouse listed at $360,000. It has been available for 107 days and needs updating. The few close completed comparables differ in tenure, condition and completion timing, so the local averages are not especially helpful.

Financing is lined up and I can be flexible on completion. Is 9% below asking sensible, or likely to end the conversation? If strengthening the offer meant keeping only one major protection, I would lean toward inspection. I’m also wary of solutions that merely shift repair or appraisal risk back to me rather than remove it.
 
After 107 days, 9% below asking is not inherently unreasonable. I would support it with the closest completed sales and proof that financing is credible, rather than trying to make the offer attractive by dropping inspection protection. On a warehouse, an updating allowance can disappear quickly once the condition is properly examined. A clean offer does not have to mean an unprotected one.
 
What does “needs updating” cover? Cosmetic finishes are one thing; work affecting the building’s use or major systems is another. That missing detail matters more than the percentage discount.

I’d also want to know whether the seller has already reduced the price or rejected earlier offers. The 107 days suggest room to negotiate, but they do not reveal the seller’s motivation.
 
One more point: set a reasonable response deadline. Too short can look theatrical when the property has sat for months; completely open-ended lets the seller hold your offer while waiting for another buyer. The exact wording and deposit consequences should be checked for the contract and jurisdiction being used.
 
I disagree slightly on leading with a detailed list of completed comparables. If those matches differ materially in tenure and condition, presenting them as precise proof of $327,600 may weaken the argument. Use them to establish a range, then explain the discount through the warehouse’s actual condition. Keep inspection, and seek repair credits only after you know what the inspection finds.
 
The appraisal gap deserves separate treatment from repairs. A repair credit can reduce cash needed at completion, but it does not guarantee the lender’s valuation will support the price. Likewise, strong financing proof reassures the seller without removing appraisal risk. Before offering, decide the maximum gap you could cover and whether you are prepared to lose the deal rather than exceed it.
 
My practical sequence would be: submit $327,600 with financing proof, flexible completion, an inspection contingency and a clear response deadline. Avoid promising in advance to cover an unlimited appraisal shortfall, and make sure the deposit is not exposed before the relevant protections expire. If the seller counters, negotiate price and inspection findings separately; otherwise you may pay more now and still inherit all the updating costs.
 
Back
Top