Rome mortgage quote: comparing 6.37% fixed over 30 years

A 6.37% rate fixed for 30 years is driving the choice on a Rome purchase of roughly €423,200. The initial headline looked more attractive, but the applicable LTV band and setup charges made the full quote less clear.

For comparing Italian offers, should I start with APR and then calculate the cash cost over the period I am likely to keep the loan? I need the lenders to use the same amount and loan-to-value basis. Monthly affordability is a separate limit, and I also want the written terms for early repayment and moving the mortgage to another property.

Timing is tight, but that is not a reason to count a verbal assurance. I’ll exclude portability or any other promised flexibility unless the paperwork states when it applies, whether a fresh assessment is required and what costs follow. I also want confirmation that the rate genuinely remains fixed for the entire 30 years, rather than resetting later.
 
I would use APR for the first pass, provided the quotes use the same loan amount and term. Then I’d calculate the cash cost over the period you realistically expect to keep the mortgage, including arrangement fees. A cheaper-looking rate can lose its advantage once upfront costs are included. Keep monthly affordability as a separate test rather than assuming the lowest total cost is automatically manageable.
 
What loan amount and LTV tier are the lenders actually using, and how long do you expect to own the property? Without those two details, even the APR comparison may not be genuinely like for like. A fee-heavy offer could look poor over five years but different over the full 30.
 
The useful outcome is a comparison based on the likely holding period, but nobody yet knows exactly how long that will be. Making total interest over all 30 years the deciding number assumes the original mortgage stays in place until maturity.

I would calculate two cases from the same loan amount and LTV: keep this mortgage for the full term, then repay or refinance after a realistic earlier date. The second case should include fees, the remaining balance and any early-repayment cost. That avoids assuming a future refinance will be available while still showing when a fee-heavy offer might recover its upfront cost.
 
Portability needs especially careful wording. Does it apply to any replacement property, and would moving require a fresh affordability or LTV assessment? The same goes for early repayment: ask exactly when charges apply and how they are calculated. If the answer is only verbal or promotional, leave it out of your financial comparison, as you’re already doing.
 
Thanks, this confirms that I need a cleaner comparison rather than one headline number. I don’t yet have every lender shown on the same loan amount and LTV basis, so that is my next request. I’ll make a table with the monthly payment, upfront fees, APR, cash cost over my likely holding period and full-term cost. I’ll also separate written early-repayment and portability terms from anything merely discussed.
 
Also clarify that “fixed for 30 years” really means fixed until final maturity, rather than a product description with some later reset. If it is fixed for the entire contractual term, the rate-reset risk sits mainly in any future refinance you choose, not in this loan itself. Finally, stress-test the monthly budget without assuming rates will be better when you want to refinance.
 
Back
Top