Seattle 5-bed at $300,000 and $1,452 rent: does 5.8% gross work?

SlowQuill

Real estate agent
The 5.8% gross yield looks thin. My specific concern is whether the quoted $1,452 monthly rent really applies to the entire five-bedroom coastal home.

The Seattle property is priced at $300,000. I have allowed for empty periods, paid management, ordinary upkeep and a substantial repair, with no appreciation assumed, but insurance and rental restrictions could still change the result. Five bedrooms may also make turnover more expensive than a simple monthly maintenance allowance suggests.

Rather than choose a target net yield first, I want to verify the inputs. I have asked for the actual property-tax figure, an insurance quote, the tenancy basis and details of a recently agreed rental in similar condition. The broker was responsive by phone, but I need those points in writing before treating the cash flow as credible.
 
Insurance would be my first line to pin down, especially given the coastal description, followed closely by the actual property-tax figure rather than an estimate. I’d also separate routine maintenance from turnover: five bedrooms can mean more wear and more work between tenancies.

Is $1,452 the rent for the entire home, and does the broker have evidence from a recently agreed comparable in similar condition? Without that, the 5.8% is too fragile to set a target net yield.
 
I wouldn’t start by choosing a net yield that “compensates” for the risk. First determine whether the deal produces positive cash flow under unfriendly assumptions. Run the rent with a longer vacancy, full management cost, a larger repair, higher insurance and property tax, then add financing at a less favourable rate if borrowing.

I also share Nadia’s concern about the rent. For a 5-bed, that number needs a clear explanation. Ask for the tenancy basis, expense history and written comparable details before spending time refining the model.
 
Back
Top