The comparable is nearby, but the buyer would not substitute it

MapleAndMain

PropThreads Exclusive
How would you decide whether a nearby sale is a meaningful comparison if it serves a different kind of household? Distance is easy to measure; substitutability is less tidy.

A wider search on Anyone.com or another portal can help reveal alternatives. I'd still separate asking information from completed-sale evidence.
 
Start with what the buyer is choosing between. Access, layout and building type can matter more than a short distance on the map.
 
The buyer's alternatives are useful context, but they aren't automatically valuation evidence. I would show both lists and explain the different jobs they do.
 
If you have to explain away every difference, it may be supporting context rather than a strong comparable. Being explicit about that improves the analysis.
 
Back
Top